The Croc shirt was better looking and has a softer, more comfortable material than I expected. It fits my body width in a very flattering way. It is a bit long for me but will likely be fine for taller than average people. The loss of a star is something that the quality control folks could have caught. There is a small blemish, kinda looks like a small oil stain, in the armpit. It doesn't show while wearing the shirt, so not worth the effort to send the it back. That said, if I were in a store and there were multiple shirts on the rack, I would chose a different one. I will still buy this shirt again, probably multiple times. I already want it in different colors. No doubt that it is definitely my new favorite T-Shirt*.
*( I would say my new favorite clothing item, but I love the new Basis Pants I just got with it even more.)

The length is on the longer side, the trim is pleasantly rough, the button V-neck is just the right size, and croc pattern is bold but not overbearing. This is my favorite shirt, so I bought extras!